Question Concerning Post from (2/6/09)

Posted by "The Man":

DO NOTHING, GIVE UP MEAT, SUGARS, ALCOHOL EAT RAW, SIMPLE, BUT A LOT MORE
EFFECTIVE
THAN RADS AND CUT. GUARANTEE YOU WILL OUTLIVE ALL ON THIS GROUP WHO THE
OTHER WAY

In response to questions concerning :

"getting close to making a decision on my primary treatment for prostate
cancer treatment" from prostwell.

If this is a treatment option, why have the Dr.s and Oncologist's not
recommended this?
I realize eating a healthy diet is a factor in good physical health.
With genetics and chromesones given to us at inception are some of us
already at risk?
Due to chemical and biological influences in our world are we not at risk by
these factors alone?
Just puzzled. Wondering if anyone saw this reply to prostwell's post and
have any input in the matter.
jloomis

jloomis wrote:
> Posted by "The Man":
>
> DO NOTHING, GIVE UP MEAT, SUGARS, ALCOHOL EAT RAW, SIMPLE, BUT A LOT MORE
> EFFECTIVE
> THAN RADS AND CUT. GUARANTEE YOU WILL OUTLIVE ALL ON THIS GROUP WHO THE
> OTHER WAY

First and foremost, what the hell's he talking about? Some meat is
healthy, we need protein, darn near everything contains some sugar,
alcohol is GOOD for us in moderation, raw is just one of many ways we
can and SHOULD eat produce (frozen is usually healthier than fresh
anyway), what the heck's a "rad" or a "cut", and we will do and live
how the heck our genetics, exercise, behaviors, luck, and diets dictate,
with NO guarantees.

The only diet proven to extend longevity is the Mediterranean diet; it
and exercise and proper sleep are probably more important than anything
and everything else, including smoking, COMBINED.

I.P.

When I read this,"GUARANTEE YOU WILL OUTLIVE ALL ON THIS GROUP WHO THE
> OTHER WAY
I was taken back by his statement.
And I wonder why he was posting on a Prostate Cancer News Group anyway?
Is it that he may have Prostate Cancer also?
I am miffed by this reply, and do realize how diet is an important factor in
Health.
jloomis
"I.P. Freely" <fuhgheddaboutit@noway.nohow> wrote in message
news:RjXWl.1622$OV3.286@newsfe04.iad...
> jloomis wrote:
>> Posted by "The Man":
>>
>> DO NOTHING, GIVE UP MEAT, SUGARS, ALCOHOL EAT RAW, SIMPLE, BUT A LOT
>> MORE
>> EFFECTIVE
>> THAN RADS AND CUT. GUARANTEE YOU WILL OUTLIVE ALL ON THIS GROUP WHO THE
>> OTHER WAY
>
> First and foremost, what the hell's he talking about? Some meat is
> healthy, we need protein, darn near everything contains some sugar,
> alcohol is GOOD for us in moderation, raw is just one of many ways we can
> and SHOULD eat produce (frozen is usually healthier than fresh anyway),
> what the heck's a "rad" or a "cut", and we will do and live how the heck
> our genetics, exercise, behaviors, luck, and diets dictate, with NO
> guarantees.
>
> The only diet proven to extend longevity is the Mediterranean diet; it and
> exercise and proper sleep are probably more important than anything and
> everything else, including smoking, COMBINED.
>
> I.P.

jloomis wrote:
> When I read this,"GUARANTEE YOU WILL OUTLIVE ALL ON THIS GROUP WHO THE
>> OTHER WAY
> I was taken back by his statement.

I saw nothing but yet another idiot pounding his keyboard with one hand
and God knows what with the other.

I guarantee you that if you eat whole wheat ice cream every Thursday and
drink bottled goat spittle while standing with your right foot on your
left elbow every Monday, you will go deaf in one thumb and your dog will
develop gills.

You tried it and neither event happened? SO SUE ME.

I.P.

I agree, I was just trying to make sense out of a statement that gets passed
around alot.......
I would like to hear some factual evidence rather than the rants and the
raves of one bimbo.
jloomis
"I.P. Freely" <fuhgheddaboutit@noway.nohow> wrote in message
news:F8%Wl.1164$h53.761@newsfe10.iad...
> jloomis wrote:
>> When I read this,"GUARANTEE YOU WILL OUTLIVE ALL ON THIS GROUP WHO THE
>>> OTHER WAY
>> I was taken back by his statement.
>
> I saw nothing but yet another idiot pounding his keyboard with one hand
> and God knows what with the other.
>
> I guarantee you that if you eat whole wheat ice cream every Thursday and
> drink bottled goat spittle while standing with your right foot on your
> left elbow every Monday, you will go deaf in one thumb and your dog will
> develop gills.
>
> You tried it and neither event happened? SO SUE ME.
>
> I.P.

jloomis wrote:
> I agree, I was just trying to make sense out of a statement that gets passed
> around alot.......
> I would like to hear some factual evidence

1. The original statement makes no sense on any level ... grammatical,
logical, biological, dietary, medical ... NADA. Some of its words are
nonsensical, it cannot be diagrammed ... it's simply unintelligible.
2. The number of whackjob claims on the internet must run in the tens of
millions. Probably < 26 of them have been subjected to respectable, peer
reviewed, double blind studies.
3. The normal way of gathering facts in this context is to ask "what
clear and rational things have been proved about [insert some specific
claim]?", not "What has been disproved or not studied?". The former is
merely an overwhelming task; the latter is effectively infinite.
4. *Maybe*, if someone can specify what the heck the OP is trying to
SHOUT -- it's little more than random words on the screen -- you can
then narrow down your question(s) to something we can address.

I.P.