Re: December 2006 monthly follow up: "Is melanoma simply a Vitamin D deficiency cancer?"

Hi curtis!

But what if melanoma is a Vitamin D deficiency cancer? Would that not
have implications for other, more-common cancers such as those of the
colon, breast, and prostate?

Thanks,
james




c palmer wrote:
> From: feetback@shoebusters.com (James Semmel)
>
> Hi curtis,
>
> Why do you think that this discussion, about whether melanoma is a
> Vitamin D deficiency cancer, is not relevant to prostate cancer?
> Thanks,
> james
>
> =====> that's just it james. you have posted repeatedly here at this
> particular newsgroup talking about melanoma. this is a prostate cancer
> newsgroup.
>
> i will address your question about vitamin D.
>
> yes, there has been research on the connection between vitamin D and
> prostate cancer. but the results are about the same as saying that
> tomatoes prevent prostate cancer. does it?
>
> i've been in the sun. i've drank a lot of milk, and i've eaten a ton
> of tomatoes and yet, i developed prostate cancer. so, what happened?
>
> now, if you want to discuss vitamin D and how it has to do with prostate
> cancer. you are most welcome. but to come here and talk about melanoma
> makes as much sense as standing inside a catholic church holding mass
> and preaching about islamism.
>
> ~ curtis
>
> knowledge is power - growing old is mandatory - growing wise is optional
> "Many more men die with prostate cancer than of it. Growing old is
> invariably fatal. Prostate cancer is only sometimes so."
> http://community.webtv.net/PALMER_ENT/doc