<!-- google_ad_section_start -->Article: The bigger your plate, the more you'll eat<!-- google_ad_section_end -->
Health Forums

Go Back   Health Forums > Fitness and Nutrition > Diet > alt.support.diet

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 11-09-2006, 08:14 AM
Diva
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Article: The bigger your plate, the more you'll eat

The bigger your plate, the more you'll eat

ANNE-MARIE TOBIN
Canadian Press
People unknowingly "booby-trap" their own homes in a way that can
lead to overeating, a nutritional expert who has conducted hundreds of
food studies said Thursday.

Bigger bowls lead to bigger servings, and if food is at hand, it
doesn't even have to be fresh for people to keep on nibbling, Brian
Wansink told a joint meeting of the Canadian Diabetes Association and
the Canadian Society of Endocrinology and Metabolism.

Some people blame obesity on fast food, the government and food
companies, but the food fight really begins at home, he said.

The solution isn't concentration and willpower, he told more than 3,000
delegates at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre.

Related to this article

Latest Comments

Well sure a nutrionists says we make 200 food decisions a day...
While the size of serving dishes is certainly a factor in food...
I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that the reason people...
Not a big surprise. For years now I have refused (other than...
10 reader comments | Join the conversation

"One thing we can start doing is start re-engineering our environment
so it mindlessly works for us, rather than against us," said
Professor Wansink, who lives in Ithaca, N.Y., and is director of the
Cornell Food and Brand Lab at Cornell University.

Most people overeat because if food is put in front of them, they'll
eat it, said Prof. Wansink, whose team has led companies to introduce
smaller size 100-calorie portions.

One study involved two groups of graduate students serving themselves
snacks from either large serving bowls in one room or smaller serving
bowls in another room at a Super Bowl party. Their individual bowls
were surreptitiously weighed, and it was found that those who served
themselves from large bowls took portions that contained 53 per cent
more calories, he said.

The bowls were coded, so that leftovers could also be tracked, and it
turned out that the group that served themselves from large bowls also
ate 59 per cent more food, in general, than the group that served
themselves from smaller bowls, Prof. Wansink said.

Another study, conducted at a Chicago movie theatre, showed that people
will even eat food that's not very good if it's in front of them.

Moviegoers at a movie were given buckets of popcorn - either freshly
popped, or five-day-old rancid popcorn.

"When people ate it, it didn't even crunch, it sort of squeaked,"
he said as he described the old popcorn, eliciting groans and laughter
from his audience.

Much of the fresh popcorn was quickly gobbled up before the credits
finished running before the movie, he said.

As for the recipients of the old popcorn, they would taste it, put it
down, wait a few minutes, then try again.

"By the end of the movie, they're still nibbling away at this, and
wincing every time they have a bite," he said.

Prof. Wansink also said his research has shown that people can reduce
their intake by replacing wide, short drinking glasses with tall
narrower ones and using smaller serving spoons.

In addition, he said plates should be filled before they're served at
the table and serving bowls should be kept off the table to avoid
mindless refilling.

Sharon Zeiler, senior manager of nutrition for the Canadian Diabetes
Association, welcomed Prof. Wansink's research, and said dietitians
have employed many of these techniques.

"Anything with science now is becoming extremely evidence-based, and
so it's wonderful to have good strong evidence," she said.

About 35 to 40 per cent of Canadian meals are eaten in restaurants, Ms.
Zeiler noted, adding that the research can be applied by restaurant
owners and people who eat at home.

Buffet-style restaurants could put salads out in smaller bowls - and
that would encourage people to take smaller portions, she said.

And for at-home buffets on occasions like Thanksgiving, Ms. Zeiler said
the hosts could use two small bowls for mashed potatoes, rather than
one huge bowl.

Food and nutrition are hot topics at the conference. Canada has more
than two million diabetics, Ms. Zeiler said, and being overweight and
not getting enough physical activity can be contributing factors for
people with Type 2.

Many people have the disease but don't realize it until symptoms like
blurry eyesight or hypertension lead to a diagnosis, she added.

According to Prof. Wansink, every day starts with a series of food
choices. At breakfast, decisions might include cereal or a bagel,
two-thirds of a bowl or a full bowl, sugar or no sugar, skim milk or 2
per cent.

"The typical person believes they make about 30 decisions related to
food a day. By the end of the day, most people have made well over 200
decisions," he said.

"But the problem is, nobody realizes that. Most of us believe we make
a few here, there and wherever. What we're not aware of is how the
environment is influencing us again and again

Diva

Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 11-09-2006, 08:14 AM
dkw12002@yahoo.com
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Article: The bigger your plate, the more you'll eat


Diva wrote:
> The bigger your plate, the more you'll eat
>
> ANNE-MARIE TOBIN
> Canadian Press
> People unknowingly "booby-trap" their own homes in a way that can
> lead to overeating, a nutritional expert who has conducted hundreds of
> food studies said Thursday.
>
> Bigger bowls lead to bigger servings, and if food is at hand, it
> doesn't even have to be fresh for people to keep on nibbling, Brian
> Wansink told a joint meeting of the Canadian Diabetes Association and
> the Canadian Society of Endocrinology and Metabolism.
>
> Some people blame obesity on fast food, the government and food
> companies, but the food fight really begins at home, he said.
>
> The solution isn't concentration and willpower, he told more than 3,000
> delegates at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre.
>
> Related to this article
>
> Latest Comments
>
> Well sure a nutrionists says we make 200 food decisions a day...
> While the size of serving dishes is certainly a factor in food...
> I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that the reason people...
> Not a big surprise. For years now I have refused (other than...
> 10 reader comments | Join the conversation
>
> "One thing we can start doing is start re-engineering our environment
> so it mindlessly works for us, rather than against us," said
> Professor Wansink, who lives in Ithaca, N.Y., and is director of the
> Cornell Food and Brand Lab at Cornell University.
>
> Most people overeat because if food is put in front of them, they'll
> eat it, said Prof. Wansink, whose team has led companies to introduce
> smaller size 100-calorie portions.
>
> One study involved two groups of graduate students serving themselves
> snacks from either large serving bowls in one room or smaller serving
> bowls in another room at a Super Bowl party. Their individual bowls
> were surreptitiously weighed, and it was found that those who served
> themselves from large bowls took portions that contained 53 per cent
> more calories, he said.
>
> The bowls were coded, so that leftovers could also be tracked, and it
> turned out that the group that served themselves from large bowls also
> ate 59 per cent more food, in general, than the group that served
> themselves from smaller bowls, Prof. Wansink said.
>
> Another study, conducted at a Chicago movie theatre, showed that people
> will even eat food that's not very good if it's in front of them.
>
> Moviegoers at a movie were given buckets of popcorn - either freshly
> popped, or five-day-old rancid popcorn.
>
> "When people ate it, it didn't even crunch, it sort of squeaked,"
> he said as he described the old popcorn, eliciting groans and laughter
> from his audience.
>
> Much of the fresh popcorn was quickly gobbled up before the credits
> finished running before the movie, he said.
>
> As for the recipients of the old popcorn, they would taste it, put it
> down, wait a few minutes, then try again.
>
> "By the end of the movie, they're still nibbling away at this, and
> wincing every time they have a bite," he said.
>
> Prof. Wansink also said his research has shown that people can reduce
> their intake by replacing wide, short drinking glasses with tall
> narrower ones and using smaller serving spoons.
>
> In addition, he said plates should be filled before they're served at
> the table and serving bowls should be kept off the table to avoid
> mindless refilling.
>
> Sharon Zeiler, senior manager of nutrition for the Canadian Diabetes
> Association, welcomed Prof. Wansink's research, and said dietitians
> have employed many of these techniques.
>
> "Anything with science now is becoming extremely evidence-based, and
> so it's wonderful to have good strong evidence," she said.
>
> About 35 to 40 per cent of Canadian meals are eaten in restaurants, Ms.
> Zeiler noted, adding that the research can be applied by restaurant
> owners and people who eat at home.
>
> Buffet-style restaurants could put salads out in smaller bowls - and
> that would encourage people to take smaller portions, she said.
>
> And for at-home buffets on occasions like Thanksgiving, Ms. Zeiler said
> the hosts could use two small bowls for mashed potatoes, rather than
> one huge bowl.
>
> Food and nutrition are hot topics at the conference. Canada has more
> than two million diabetics, Ms. Zeiler said, and being overweight and
> not getting enough physical activity can be contributing factors for
> people with Type 2.
>
> Many people have the disease but don't realize it until symptoms like
> blurry eyesight or hypertension lead to a diagnosis, she added.
>
> According to Prof. Wansink, every day starts with a series of food
> choices. At breakfast, decisions might include cereal or a bagel,
> two-thirds of a bowl or a full bowl, sugar or no sugar, skim milk or 2
> per cent.
>
> "The typical person believes they make about 30 decisions related to
> food a day. By the end of the day, most people have made well over 200
> decisions," he said.
>
> "But the problem is, nobody realizes that. Most of us believe we make
> a few here, there and wherever. What we're not aware of is how the
> environment is influencing us again and again
>
> Diva


I think that smaller portions and smaller bowls might work for some,
but not for others, because they have a buffet mentality. They tend to
eat as long as their is food available getting seconds and thirds of
the smaller portions, then looking for something else to eat. I wish
the smaller bowls and smaller portions would work, but overweight
people are not likely to be fooled by this trick, I think. Perhaps it
might work to have mostly low-cal foods on hand and MAYBE people would
fill up on those instead of higher-calorie food. Problem is nothing is
preventing the person from eating, then heading out to the supermarket
or McDonalds. I'm afraid overeating is much more complex an issue than
bowl size and portion size...still, it can't hurt. For overweight
people, it takes a sincere effort and lifestyle change to overcome the
weight problem. Then, eating correct amounts and perhaps exercising
must become a preoccupation perhaps akin to a religion or pursuing some
long-term goal like a college degree..at least for the seriously
overweight. If someone has only a minor overweight condition, lots of
things probably work including eliminating cream from coffee, late
night snacking, etc. dkw

Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 11-09-2006, 08:14 AM
Diva
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Article: The bigger your plate, the more you'll eat


dkw12002@yahoo.com wrote:
> Diva wrote:
> > The bigger your plate, the more you'll eat
> >
> > ANNE-MARIE TOBIN
> > Canadian Press
> > People unknowingly "booby-trap" their own homes in a way that can
> > lead to overeating, a nutritional expert who has conducted hundreds of
> > food studies said Thursday.
> >
> > Bigger bowls lead to bigger servings, and if food is at hand, it
> > doesn't even have to be fresh for people to keep on nibbling, Brian
> > Wansink told a joint meeting of the Canadian Diabetes Association and
> > the Canadian Society of Endocrinology and Metabolism.
> >
> > Some people blame obesity on fast food, the government and food
> > companies, but the food fight really begins at home, he said.
> >
> > The solution isn't concentration and willpower, he told more than 3,000
> > delegates at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre.
> >
> > Related to this article
> >
> > Latest Comments
> >
> > Well sure a nutrionists says we make 200 food decisions a day...
> > While the size of serving dishes is certainly a factor in food...
> > I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that the reason people...
> > Not a big surprise. For years now I have refused (other than...
> > 10 reader comments | Join the conversation
> >
> > "One thing we can start doing is start re-engineering our environment
> > so it mindlessly works for us, rather than against us," said
> > Professor Wansink, who lives in Ithaca, N.Y., and is director of the
> > Cornell Food and Brand Lab at Cornell University.
> >
> > Most people overeat because if food is put in front of them, they'll
> > eat it, said Prof. Wansink, whose team has led companies to introduce
> > smaller size 100-calorie portions.
> >
> > One study involved two groups of graduate students serving themselves
> > snacks from either large serving bowls in one room or smaller serving
> > bowls in another room at a Super Bowl party. Their individual bowls
> > were surreptitiously weighed, and it was found that those who served
> > themselves from large bowls took portions that contained 53 per cent
> > more calories, he said.
> >
> > The bowls were coded, so that leftovers could also be tracked, and it
> > turned out that the group that served themselves from large bowls also
> > ate 59 per cent more food, in general, than the group that served
> > themselves from smaller bowls, Prof. Wansink said.
> >
> > Another study, conducted at a Chicago movie theatre, showed that people
> > will even eat food that's not very good if it's in front of them.
> >
> > Moviegoers at a movie were given buckets of popcorn - either freshly
> > popped, or five-day-old rancid popcorn.
> >
> > "When people ate it, it didn't even crunch, it sort of squeaked,"
> > he said as he described the old popcorn, eliciting groans and laughter
> > from his audience.
> >
> > Much of the fresh popcorn was quickly gobbled up before the credits
> > finished running before the movie, he said.
> >
> > As for the recipients of the old popcorn, they would taste it, put it
> > down, wait a few minutes, then try again.
> >
> > "By the end of the movie, they're still nibbling away at this, and
> > wincing every time they have a bite," he said.
> >
> > Prof. Wansink also said his research has shown that people can reduce
> > their intake by replacing wide, short drinking glasses with tall
> > narrower ones and using smaller serving spoons.
> >
> > In addition, he said plates should be filled before they're served at
> > the table and serving bowls should be kept off the table to avoid
> > mindless refilling.
> >
> > Sharon Zeiler, senior manager of nutrition for the Canadian Diabetes
> > Association, welcomed Prof. Wansink's research, and said dietitians
> > have employed many of these techniques.
> >
> > "Anything with science now is becoming extremely evidence-based, and
> > so it's wonderful to have good strong evidence," she said.
> >
> > About 35 to 40 per cent of Canadian meals are eaten in restaurants, Ms.
> > Zeiler noted, adding that the research can be applied by restaurant
> > owners and people who eat at home.
> >
> > Buffet-style restaurants could put salads out in smaller bowls - and
> > that would encourage people to take smaller portions, she said.
> >
> > And for at-home buffets on occasions like Thanksgiving, Ms. Zeiler said
> > the hosts could use two small bowls for mashed potatoes, rather than
> > one huge bowl.
> >
> > Food and nutrition are hot topics at the conference. Canada has more
> > than two million diabetics, Ms. Zeiler said, and being overweight and
> > not getting enough physical activity can be contributing factors for
> > people with Type 2.
> >
> > Many people have the disease but don't realize it until symptoms like
> > blurry eyesight or hypertension lead to a diagnosis, she added.
> >
> > According to Prof. Wansink, every day starts with a series of food
> > choices. At breakfast, decisions might include cereal or a bagel,
> > two-thirds of a bowl or a full bowl, sugar or no sugar, skim milk or 2
> > per cent.
> >
> > "The typical person believes they make about 30 decisions related to
> > food a day. By the end of the day, most people have made well over 200
> > decisions," he said.
> >
> > "But the problem is, nobody realizes that. Most of us believe we make
> > a few here, there and wherever. What we're not aware of is how the
> > environment is influencing us again and again
> >
> > Diva

>
> I think that smaller portions and smaller bowls might work for some,
> but not for others, because they have a buffet mentality. They tend to
> eat as long as their is food available getting seconds and thirds of
> the smaller portions, then looking for something else to eat. I wish
> the smaller bowls and smaller portions would work, but overweight
> people are not likely to be fooled by this trick, I think. Perhaps it
> might work to have mostly low-cal foods on hand and MAYBE people would
> fill up on those instead of higher-calorie food. Problem is nothing is
> preventing the person from eating, then heading out to the supermarket
> or McDonalds. I'm afraid overeating is much more complex an issue than
> bowl size and portion size...still, it can't hurt. For overweight
> people, it takes a sincere effort and lifestyle change to overcome the
> weight problem. Then, eating correct amounts and perhaps exercising
> must become a preoccupation perhaps akin to a religion or pursuing some
> long-term goal like a college degree..at least for the seriously
> overweight. If someone has only a minor overweight condition, lots of
> things probably work including eliminating cream from coffee, late
> night snacking, etc. dkw


I diid solve the buffet problem by only taking one trip and never
piling food up but keeping it flat and well within the rim of the
plate. I don't approach the desert table unless there is fresh fruit.
Being celiac would make it painful to cheat on pastries.

Diva

Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 11-09-2006, 08:14 AM
Manco
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default Re: Article: The bigger your plate, the more you'll eat

dkw12002@yahoo.com wrote:
>> Most people overeat because if food is put in front of them, they'll
>> eat it, said Prof. Wansink, whose team has led companies to introduce
>> smaller size 100-calorie portions.
>>


Doh. Isn't the answer simple willpower no matter how big or small the plate?
The willpower to say I'm only going to eat this one small/medium portion and
no more?


Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is Off
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are On
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Article on DaVinci RML alt.support.cancer.prostate 2 11-10-2006 10:07 PM
inspiring article LFM alt.support.diet 1 11-09-2006 08:12 AM
Article on MSNBC.com Anonomouse alt.support.diet 0 11-09-2006 08:10 AM
Second try for article JohnHace alt.support.cancer.prostate 4 11-09-2006 03:10 AM
Article on Januvia Chrome alt.support.diabetes 9 11-08-2006 09:12 PM


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:13 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2008, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.2.0
     
   
 

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41